| Barium Inhibition of the Collapse of the Shaker K Conductance in Zero K Biophysical Journal, Volume 77, Issue 6, 1 December 1999, Pages 2988-2998 Froylán Gómez-Lagunas Abstract In the absence of K on both sides of the membrane, delivery of standard activating pulses collapses the B K conductance. Prolonged depolarizations restore the ability to conduct K. It has been proposed that the collapse of the conductance results from the dwelling of the channels in a stable closed (noninactivated) state (Gómez-Lagunas, 1997, 499:3–15). Here it is shown that 1) Ba impedes the collapse of the K conductance, protecting it from both sides of the membrane; 2) external Ba protection (=63M at −80mV) decreases slightly as the holding potential (HP) is made more negative; 3) external Ba cannot restore the previously collapsed conductance; on the other hand, 4) internal Ba (and K) protection markedly decreases with hyperpolarized HPs (−80 to −120mV), and it is not dependent on the pulse potential (0 to +60mV). Ba is an effective K substitute, inhibiting the passage of the channels into the stable nonconducting (noninactivated) mode of gating. Abstract | Full Text | PDF (215 kb) |
| Loss of Shaker K Channel Conductance in 0K Solutions: Role of the Voltage Sensor Biophysical Journal, Volume 75, Issue 4, 1 October 1998, Pages 1828-1835 Alexey Melishchuk, Andrey Loboda and Clay M. Armstrong Abstract In potassium-free solutions some types of K channels enter a long-lasting nonconducting or “defunct” state. It is known that K channels must open in K-free solutions to become defunct. Gating current studies presented here indicate an abnormal conformation in the defunct state that restricts S4 movement and alters its kinetics. Thus an abnormality initiated in the P region spreads to the gating apparatus. We find that channels most readily become defunct on repolarization to an intermediate voltage, thus prolonging occupancy of one of the several intermediate closed states. The state dependence of becoming defunct was further dissected by using the gating mutant L382A. Simply closing this channel at 0mV (reversing the last activation step) does not make the mutant channel defunct. Instead, it is necessary to move further left (more fully closed) in the activation sequence. This was confirmed with IR experiments showing that channels become defunct only if there is inward gating charge movement. Rapid transit through the intermediate states, achieved at very negative voltage, is relatively ineffective at making channels defunct. Several mutations that removed C-type inactivation also made the channels resistant to becoming defunct. Our results show that normal gating current cannot be stably recorded in the absence of K. Abstract | Full Text | PDF (187 kb) |
| Role of N-Terminal Domain and Accessory Subunits in Controlling Deactivation-Inactivation Coupling of Kv4.2 Channels Biophysical Journal, Volume 94, Issue 4, 15 February 2008, Pages 1276-1294 Jan Barghaan, Magdalini Tozakidou, Heimo Ehmke and Robert Bähring Abstract We examined the relationship between deactivation and inactivation in Kv4.2 channels. In particular, we were interested in the role of a Kv4.2 N-terminal domain and accessory subunits in controlling macroscopic gating kinetics and asked if the effects of N-terminal deletion and accessory subunit coexpression conform to a kinetic coupling of deactivation and inactivation. We expressed Kv4.2 wild-type channels and N-terminal deletion mutants in the absence and presence of Kv channel interacting proteins (KChIPs) and dipeptidyl aminopeptidase-like proteins (DPPs) in human embryonic kidney 293 cells. Kv4.2-mediated A-type currents at positive and deactivation tail currents at negative membrane potentials were recorded under whole-cell voltage-clamp and analyzed by multi-exponential fitting. The observed changes in Kv4.2 macroscopic inactivation kinetics caused by N-terminal deletion, accessory subunit coexpression, or a combination of the two maneuvers were compared with respective changes in deactivation kinetics. Extensive correlation analyses indicated that modulatory effects on deactivation closely parallel respective effects on inactivation, including both onset and recovery kinetics. Searching for the structural determinants, which control deactivation and inactivation, we found that in a Kv4.2Δ2–10 N-terminal deletion mutant both the initial rapid phase of macroscopic inactivation and tail current deactivation were slowed. On the other hand, the intermediate and slow phase of A-type current decay, recovery from inactivation, and tail current decay kinetics were accelerated in Kv4.2Δ2–10 by KChIP2 and DPPX. Thus, a Kv4.2 N-terminal domain, which may control both inactivation and deactivation, is not necessary for active modulation of current kinetics by accessory subunits. Our results further suggest distinct mechanisms for Kv4.2 gating modulation by KChIPs and DPPs. Abstract | Full Text | PDF (1846 kb) |
Copyright © 2007 The Biophysical Society. All rights reserved.
Biophysical Journal, Volume 93, Issue 12, 4197-4208, 15 December 2007
doi:10.1529/biophysj.106.095794
Channels, Receptors, and Electrical Signaling
Address reprint requests to Froylán Gómez-Lagunas, Facultad de Medicina, Dept. Fisiologia, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Ciudad Universitaria, Apartado Postal 70-250 Mexico D.F. 04510, Mexico. Tel.: 555-623-2263.Potassium ions are known to play important roles in the operation of voltage-dependent K+ channels (Kv channels). Although it is known that K+ ions affect the functionality of these proteins (i.e., the stability, selectivity, and the conformational changes referred to as gating), they affect different Kv channels in quite different ways. When the conservation of the signature sequence and the associated selectivity filter of the pore, which contains the only K+ binding sites visible in crystallographic structures of K+-selective pores 1,2,3, are taken into account, this variability of effects is surprising, and it can be said that its mechanistic bases are not yet well understood.
One general observation is that K+ ions are a necessary cofactor for stability of the functional conformation of the channels (i.e., K+ ions are needed to keep K channels in a conformation able to conduct permeant ions), although exceptions are known of channels that remain quite stable in the absence of K+ (see below).
The role of K+ ions in K channel stability is best observed when the channels are exposed to 0 K+ solutions on both sides of the membrane: pioneering work by Chandler and Meves (1970) 4 and Almers and Armstrong (1980) 5 using the squid giant axon show that the K+ current (IK) and associated gating currents are irreversibly lost on bathing the axon with 0 K+ (not added) solutions on both sides of the membrane, revealing for the first time the relevant role of K+ in Kv channel stability. Nonetheless and interestingly, other channels present different responses to K+ depletion. For example, both Kv1.3 and Ca2+-dependent maxi-K channels remain functional after being exposed to 0 K+ solutions 6,7. Similarly, Kv2.1, Kv1.5, and delayed rectifier channels of bullfrog neurons remain stable but lose their selectivity, allowing a substantial Na+ flux in the absence of K+8,9,10,11. In contrast, the KcsA channel selectivity filter adopts an anomalous, nonconducting, conformation with low (3mM) K+12, and the thermal stability of its tetrameric structure is undermined in the absence of either permeant or blocking ions 13.
In the case of Shaker B, it has been shown that these channels remain stable in the absence of K+ on both sides of the membrane as long as they are kept undisturbed (closed) at the holding potential (HP). However, if the channels undergo gating cycles in 0 K+, evoked with the delivery of activating pulses, the conductance collapses. The extent of collapse depends both on the number of activating pulses and on the [Na+] in the 0 K+ solutions. It is thought that the drop of GK occurs during the closing of the channels, at the end of each activating pulse. The collapse of GK is completely reversed by very prolonged depolarizations 14,15. During the collapsed (nonconducting) state of GK, the channels nonetheless continue to exhibit gating currents. In other words, closing a Shaker channel in a 0 K+ solution containing Na+ will uncouple, in a fully reversible manner, the movement of the voltage sensor from the conduction state of the pore 16,17.
It was shown recently that delayed rectifier Shab channels, which share an identical signature sequence with the related Shaker B channel, are fairly stable in solutions lacking K+ on only one side of the membrane (either internal or external), although interestingly, its stability is significantly greater with K+ present in the external solution. However, if the channels are exposed to 0 K+ (not added) solutions, on both sides of the membrane, GK collapses. Notably, and in contrast with Shaker behavior, the collapse of Shab GK occurs while the channels are kept undisturbed at the HP (HP=−80mV), and it is irreversible. Furthermore, the extent of collapse is similar for 0 K+ solutions containing Na+, NMG+, or choline+ ions 18. That is, the stabilizing K+ ion(s) readily dissociate from the apparently closed Shab channels when the cell is perfused with 0 K+ solutions. These observations prompted the hypothesis that there could be a site (or sites) located in the external vestibule of the pore, outside the selectivity filter, where K+ binding would allosterically maintain GK stable 18.
To test the previously mentioned hypothesis regarding a possible stabilizing K+ site located outside the selectivity filter (and therefore outside of the voltage drop across the membrane 19), and also to test the possibility that the dissociation of the stabilizing K+ could occur while channels are closed (deactivated) at the HP, the voltage dependence of the Shab GK collapse in 0 K+ was studied.
Here it is reported that: 1), GK decay follows a first-order kinetics, with a decay rate that, unexpectedly, presents a strong voltage dependence, such that hyperpolarized potentials dramatically inhibit the GK drop in 0 K+; 2), GK collapse at negative voltages cannot be accounted for by a shift in the voltage dependence of the activation of the channels; but 3), delivery of activating pulses from the stabilizing HP of −140mV somewhat facilitates the drop of GK. On the other hand, it is also reported that 4), at depolarized potentials, where the channels undergo a slow inactivation process, the drop of GK becomes much slower than predicted, based on the trend observed at negative voltages.
These novel observations are consistent with the hypothesized presence of one or more stabilizing K+ sites located either within the pore itself or in the pore’s outer vestibule, at a location affected by the conformational change associated with the slow inactivation of the channels.
Insect Spodoptera frugiperda Sf9 cells were grown at 27°C in Grace’s medium (Gibco, Grand Island, NY). Cells were infected with a multiplicity of infection of 10 with a recombinant baculovirus containing Shab (dShab 11) K+-channel cDNA, as previously reported 18,20. The experiments were conducted 48–72h after infection of the cells.
Macroscopic currents were recorded under whole-cell patch clamp with an Axopatch 1D amplifier (Axon Instruments). Unless otherwise indicated, currents were filtered on line at 5kHz with the built-in filter of the amplifier and sampled at 100μs/point, with a Digidata 1322A interface (Axon Instruments, MDS, Sunnyvale, CA). The electrodes were made of borosilicate glass (KIMAX 51) pulled to a 1–1.5MΩ resistance. Eighty percent of the series resistance was compensated. Unless otherwise indicated the HP was −80mV. Experiments were carried out at room temperature, as previously reported 18.
Solutions referred to herein will be named by their main cation and their location with respect to the membrane, e.g., Nai.
Complete exchange of the bath solution occurred within 3–4s as evaluated by the change in the equilibrium potential of K+ (data not shown), which is less than 10% of the smallest GK decay time constant reported herein; thus, no correction was applied to the reported times in 0 K+.
The GK drop in 0 K+ follows first-order kinetics (Fig. 1, see Results). Thus, the decay constant r of the process does not depend on [K+] in initial control solutions (i.e., r does not depend on the initial amount of functional, available-to-conduct, AK channels harboring stabilizing K+ ions in them). Therefore, curves showing the GK drop as a function of time spent in 0 K+ were obtained from experiments with XKo/Nai initial control solutions having a variable potassium concentration X (mM), that depended on the number of channels (size of IK) present in the corresponding cells.
Results are expressed as the mean±SE of the indicated number of experiments. When necessary, the t-test was used to evaluate statistical significance. Curves were fitted with the SigmaPlot version 8.0 (SPPSS) Marquardt-Levenberg algorithm.
On exposure to 0 K+ (not added) solutions on both sides of the membrane, Shab channels cease to conduct K+. The irreversible collapse of the Shab conductance (GK) is illustrated in Figure 1A, which presents a control IK (left panel, Before) evoked by a 0-mV/30-ms activating pulse in Ko/Nai solutions (see Methods). After checking of IK stability (not shown), the cell was superfused with the 0 K+, Nao solution (Nao/Nai) for 5min, with the channels kept undisturbed (closed, see below) at the HP of −80mV (as indicated by the arrow). Finally, the cell was returned to the control Ko solution and, ∼30s later, the channels’ ability to conduct K+ was tested with the delivery of an activating pulse (right panel). There was a substantial reduction of IK, which demonstrates that, on exposure to 0 K+ solutions, the majority of the channels lose their ability to conduct ions.
To learn more about the nature of the physical process underlying the drop of GK, the kinetics of the collapse was studied. The results in Figure 1B report GK decay as a function of the time spent in 0 K+, from experiments such as those depicted in Figure 1A. The GK drop at time t is measured by the ratio I(t)/I0, where I(t) is the K+ current remaining after t minutes in 0 K+, and I0 is the control current. Note that GK decay follows an exponential time course (line through the points), which indicates that, during exposure to 0 K+, GK undergoes a first-order decay reaction as the channels proceed from an initial available-to-conduct state, with K+ bound to them (AK), to a final unable-to-conduct state (U), reached once the stabilizing K+ leaves the channels, with a decay rate r of 0.72min−1 at the HP of −80mV, as indicated by the kinetic scheme in the figure. The first-order kinetics of the collapse of GK indicates that r does not depend on the [K+] in the initial control solutions (see Methods). It is pertinent to point out that after the dissociation of the stabilizing K+, a conformational change must take place that sinks the channels into the final state U. This intermediate step is not shown in the kinetic scheme of the figure (see Discussion).
The results in Fig. 1 demonstrate that the stabilizing K+ (i.e., the K+ ion(s) that maintain(s) the channels able to conduct) is located at a site(s) from which it is easily removed by just washing the cell with the Nao solution despite the negative membrane potential that should attract positive K+ ions. This suggests that the stabilizing K+ site(s) could be located in a superficial location, such as the external vestibule of the pore, outside the selectivity filter, and the voltage drop across the membrane, as previously proposed (see Introduction). The latter implies that GK decay should not be affected by the membrane potential. To test this possibility the drop of GK in 0 K+ was studied at several membrane potentials.
Fig. 2 compares the extent of the GK drop obtained at the HP of −80mV, as in Figure 1A, with that obtained at the HP of −140mV during a 5-min exposure of the cells to 0 K+ solutions. The left panel in Figure 2A shows a control IK, evoked by a −10-mV/30-ms test pulse applied from the usual HP of −80mV in Ko/Nai solutions (Before). Thereafter, the HP was shifted to −140mV, and 15s later, the cell was superfused with the, 0 K+, Nao solution (Nao/Nai) for 5min, with the HP maintained at −140mV (not shown, indicated by the arrow). Then, the cell was returned to the control Ko solution, the HP was shifted back to −80mV, and the state of the channels was tested, as in the control. The size of IK in the middle panel demonstrates that the GK drop was surprisingly small at the HP of −140mV.
Subsequently, and after the trace in the middle panel had been recorded, to better compare the HP effect on GK stability, the cell was immersed again in 0 K+ (Nao/Nai) solutions for 5min, but this time with the HP at −80mV, after which, with the cell back in the Ko solution, the activity of the channels was tested. The trace in the right panel shows that, as expected, there was a nearly complete GK drop (∼90%). The effect of the voltage on the drop of GK is best observed in Figure 2B, which presents the average drop after a 5-min exposure to 0 K+ with the HP at either −80mV (93±2.5%, n=4) or −140mV (17±4%, n=5), as indicated. Clearly, the hyperpolarized membrane potential drastically inhibits the collapse of GK in 0 K+.
Figure 3A presents GK drop as a function of HP and of time spent in 0 K+ solutions, from experiments as in Figure 1B. Note that regardless of the HP, GK decay follows an exponential time course, as expected, and the rate of decay becomes progressively and significantly slower as the HP becomes more negative. Thus, as shown previously, at −140mV the channels become quite stable in 0 K+. GK decay is so slow that, within the time span considered, the fall of the current approaches the linear variation of an exponential function at times smaller than its corresponding time constant.
The above results demonstrate that the rate of decay, r, is voltage dependent. This is best observed in Figure 3B, which presents a plot of r against the HP during channel exposure to 0 K+ solutions. Note that r varies in a nonlinear fashion with the voltage. As a first approximation (see below and Discussion), the points were fitted with an exponential function plus an offset (line through the points): rn(V)=0.01+86exp(0.06V), where the subscript n stands for negative voltages (V≤−80mV). It is interesting that this equation has the monoexponential form of the G-V relationship of voltage-dependent channels at voltages where the probability of opening is low (e.g., 21,22, plus an offset. However, until we know more regarding the factors involved in GK stabilization, we should be cautious in affording a physical interpretation to its parameters. The exception is the small offset (0.01min−1), which has a clear physical meaning: it suggests that, even when hyperpolarized potentials confer a striking stability to the channels, no matter how negative the potential could be there would always be an exponential, although quite slow, GK decay in 0 K+.
The observations in Figure 2 and Figure 3 demonstrate that, unexpectedly, the collapse of GK in 0 K+ is markedly voltage dependent. This finding suggests the following possibilities regarding the mechanism for GK drop: 1), that at the negative potentials studied, the stabilizing K+ could leave the channels during their rare stochastic openings, which are expected to occur more frequently at −80 than at −140mV (as suggested by the form of rn(V)); 2), that the voltage dependence of the activation of the channels could be significantly shifted to the left in 0 K+, so that the channels would be open at negative potentials, with more of them being open at −80mV than at more negative potentials; or 3), that the channels are not tightly closed by the cytoplasmic activation gate at −80mV (i.e., that the closed conformation of the activation gate could allow the leakage of K+ ions), and that closing becomes tighter at more negative potentials (e.g., 23,24. It is pertinent to point out that these possibilities share the common characteristic of considering that the huge stabilization afforded by hyperpolarized potentials arises from a reduced exit of the stabilizing K+ ions, from either the open or the closed state of the channels. The experiments that follow were conducted to distinguish among these possibilities.
To explore the possibility that channel activation could be significantly shifted toward hyperpolarized potentials in 0 K+ solutions, the conductance-versus-voltage relationship of the channels was studied at several [K+] across the membrane. Figure 4A shows IK obtained in two cells expressing different numbers of channels. Currents were activated by 100-ms pulses from −70 to +50mV, applied every 5s in 10-mV increments from the HP of −90mV in either 100mM
or 2mM
solutions, as indicated. For clarity, the figure shows the current at every other pulse beginning at −60mV. The traces indicate that the activation of the channels is not significantly shifted to negative potentials when [K+] is decreased. The latter is best seen in Figure 4B, which presents the average GK-Vm relationship at several [K+] across the membrane. Note that, interestingly, despite the critical role of K+ in GK stability, the GK-Vm relationship is not importantly affected by the [K+] across the membrane (see legend to Fig. 4).
or 2mM
solutions, as indicated (see text). (B) GK versus pulse potential. GK was obtained from the relative, isochronal, tail currents at −80mV Itail(V)/Imax, where Itail(V) is the amplitude of the tail current at the end of the pulse potential V, and Imax is the maximal amplitude of the tail currents. V was varied from −70 to +50mV in 10-mV steps. In the experiments in Nao/Ki, the tail currents were measured at a repolarization potential of −60mV. The points are the mean±SE of at least four experiments at each [K+]. The lines are fit to the points with Boltzmann functions, as indicated: 2Ko/Nai: V½=−33.3mV, z=2.7; 20Ko/Nai: V½=−31.2mV, z=2.4; 100Ko/Nai: V½=−31.2mV, z=2.6; Nao/Ki: V½=−29.3, z=3.3.Incidentally, it is also pertinent to note that Shab channels conduct K+ well even with only 2mM K+ in the recording solutions. Moreover, as mentioned above, the GK-Vm relationship in 2mM K+ (solid circles) is not much different from that obtained in high, 100mM, K+ conditions (solid triangles). The latter is in contrast with the behavior of KcsA channels, where the pore adopts a nonconducting, collapsed, conformation in the presence of 3mM K+12 (see Discussion).
The results in Fig. 4 suggest that the drop of GK at −80mV, as well as the protection afforded by hyperpolarized potentials, cannot be explained by a significant shift of the voltage dependence of activation of the channels toward negative potentials in the absence of K+. Accordingly, the next question is whether the explanation is that channels are not tightly closed at −80mV (i.e., if the closed conformation of the cytoplasmic activation gate allows leakage of the critical K+ ions toward the internal solution), and whether channels close tighter at hyperpolarized membrane potentials? If this were the case, it would be expected that any manipulation that facilitates K+ exit from the channels would also enhance the drop of GK. Therefore, to gain some insight regarding this point, the effect of repeated activation of the channels in 0 K+ solutions, from the protecting HP of −140mV, was studied.
Fig. 5 reports the effect of the delivery of 10 short activating, 0-mV/5-ms, pulses (referred to as pulsing) applied from the HP of −140mV at the rate of 1Hz during a total 1.5-min exposure of the cells to 0 K+ solutions. The 5-ms pulse duration was chosen because a significant percentage of the channels would be opened by each pulse, whereas, on the other hand, the total time spent at 0mV (50ms) would alone account for 0.05% of the total time at −140mV in 0 K+. Finally, the delivery of one pulse every second from −140mV allows a full recovery from inactivation (in Nao/Ki solutions F. Gomez-Lagunas and D. Balleza, unpublished observations, and see below). Therefore, the experimental conditions guarantee that whatever the observed reduction of GK may be, it could not be interpreted as the result of the time spent at a potential different from the stabilizing −140mV.
Figure 5A (left panel) is a control IK evoked by a 0-mV/30-ms pulse applied from −80mV in Ko/Nai (Before). Thereafter, the HP was changed to −140mV, and 15s later the cell was superfused with the Nao solution, and 10 0-mV/5-ms pulses were applied at 1Hz (not shown, indicated by the arrow). Finally, after 1.5min in 0 K+, the cell was returned to the Ko solution, the HP was shifted back to −80mV, and the current in the right panel was recorded, as in the control. There was only a scant reduction of IK.
The latter result is best appreciated in Figure 5B, which presents the average GK drop obtained from experiments as in A. Notice that the difference in the extent of drop that occurs either just passively (i.e., without pulses, left bar, 5.9±1.5%, n=8) or with the added effect of the repeated pulses (right bar, 9.6±2.8%, n=7) is small (not statistically different, p>0.05) but nevertheless noticeable; moreover, if the pulse duration is increased to 30ms to allow the full activation of the channels on each pulse, then the GK drop increases ∼6% over the value obtained with the shorter pulses (GK drop=15.2±1.8%, n=5; not shown). The above observations indicate that the activation of the channels somewhat facilitates the drop of GK (by comparison, at −80mV, without pulsing, GK drops ∼74% after 1.5min in 0 K+). Thus, it seems that part of the stabilizing effect of hyperpolarized HPs arises from a reduced exit of K+ ions from the channels. The latter could be produced either by a tighter closing of the activation gate or by a reduction of the probability of opening as the membrane becomes hyperpolarized or both (see Discussion). Finally, it is pertinent to mention that these results also show that the behavior of Shab is different from that of Shaker channels whose GK collapses in a reversible manner only with delivery of activating pulses in 0 K+ such that a single pulse produces an ∼40% drop of GK.
The variation of the decay rate, r, with voltage (Fig. 4) predicts that GK should decay rapidly at depolarized potentials. Specifically, at 0mV we would expect r(0)=86min−1; thus, after a brief 50-s exposure of the cell to 0 K+ solutions, GK should drop completely. Fig. 6 presents a test of this prediction. The figure shows 2 IK recorded in Ko/Nai solutions; the current in the left panel is a control IK (Before), whereas the right panel shows the IK left after the cell has been bathed in 0 K+ (Nao/Nai) solutions for 50s, with the HP=0mV (not shown, indicated by the arrow). Clearly, there still remains a substantial fraction of the control IK (∼50%). Therefore, GK decay at 0mV is much smaller than its predicted drop, based on the trend observed at negative potentials.
A possible explanation for the above discrepancy is that whereas within the range of negative potentials, at which the r-Vm relationship was studied (Fig. 3), the drop of GK likely occurs while the channels are closed (Figure 4 and Figure 5, and see Discussion), at 0mV the GK drop (i.e., the dissociation of the stabilizing K+) probably occurs while the channels are inactivated. On inactivation the K+ conductance drops. Moreover, the typical, C-type, slow inactivation is thought to involve a partial closure of the extracellular portion of the pore (see Discussion). Therefore, in the case of Shab, it would be expected that the exit of the critical K+ ions would be either halted or delayed if channels were slowly inactivated during the exposure to 0 K+ solutions at 0mV.
Therefore, to gain insight into this point, Fig. 7 presents the most basic characteristics of the slow inactivation of Shab channels, together with a test to best assess whether GK actually collapses in 0 K+ once the channels have been inactivated. Figure 7A (left panel) presents a reference IK evoked by a short 0-mV/30-ms pulse under standard recording conditions (Nao/Ki solutions). As expected, there is no inactivation during the pulse, but if its duration is increased to 7s, then a slow inactivation of the channels becomes apparent (right panel). Preliminary observations indicate that, in contrast to the C-type inactivation of Shaker channels, external K+ does not slow the rate of inactivation of Shab (work in progress, not shown).
(open circles, slashed line) solutions. I(prepulse)/Imax, is the ratio of IK evoked by the test pulse that followed the indicated prepulse potential, I(prepulse), to the maximal IK, Imax, evoked by the test pulse. The points are the mean±SE of n=4 experiments in each condition. The lines are the fit of the points with the Boltzmann equation: I(prepulse)/Imax=1/(1+exp((zF/RT)(Vm-V½))), where F, R, and T have their usual meaning. In Nao/Ki: V½=−56.3mV, z=4.6; 100Ko/Ki: V½=−53mV, z=5.0. HP=−80mV. (C) Collapse of GK from inactivated channels. GK drop after either a 1.5- (left bars) or a 5-min (right bars) exposure to 0K (Nao/Nai) solutions at 0mV, as a function of time (0.25 or 1min) at which the HP was shifted from −80 to 0mV before the perfusion of the Nao solution, as indicated (see text).Thus, to better understand the role of the HP in GK stability in 0 K+, the steady-state inactivation of the channels was studied as a function of [
]. Figure 7B shows that with standard [K+] inside the cell (Ki), the parameters of the steady-state inactivation curve (hereafter also referred to as h∞) change only slightly on removal of the external K+ (Nao/Ki (solid circles, solid line): V½=−56.3mV, z=4.5;
(open circles, dashed line): V½=−53mV, z=5.0). Therefore, at the HP of 0mV the channels are inactivated at steady state regardless of the external [K+]. The latter suggests that the GK drop at 0mV (Fig. 6) probably occurred while the channels were at the indicated level of steady-state inactivation.
This possibility is further examined with the experiments in Figure 7C that compare the percentage reduction of GK obtained when the HP is switched from −80 to 0mV either 15s (as commonly done, as in Figure 3 and Figure 4 and Figure 5 and Figure 6) or 1min before the cell immersion in the Nao solution (undoubtedly sufficient time to ensure steady-state conditions). The bars in the figure demonstrate that, regardless of the time at which the HP was shifted, there are no significant differences (p>0.05) in the extent of GK drop attained after either a 50-s (solid bars) or a 5-min (open bars) exposure to 0 K+, as indicated. Thus, changing the HP 50s before going to 0 K+ allows the channels to reach their steady-state level of inactivation.
The above observations, along with the trend observed at negative potentials, indicate that the development of inactivation greatly slows the rate of decay of GK (see Discussion). The latter point is further tested below.
If the development of inactivation at depolarized voltages actually slows the decay of GK, then, according to the h∞ curves, its decay should be faster at intermediate potentials (e.g., −50mV), at which not all of the channels are inactivated, than at more depolarized potentials (e.g., at −30 or 0mV) at which all channels should be inactivated at steady state. Figure 8A tests this prediction by comparing the time course of the drop of GK at 0mV with that obtained at the HPs of either −50 (left panel) or −30mV (right panel). Note that GK decay is clearly faster at −50 (r(−50)=1.78min−1) than at 0mV (r(0)=0.9min−1). On the other hand, the decay rate at 0mV is comparable to, although quantitatively slightly slower than, that at −30mV (r(−30)=1.36min−1). These results are in qualitative agreement with the hypothesis proposing that inactivation slows the decay of GK. The difference in decay rates at 0 and at −30mV can be accounted for by means of the hypothesis that there is a small shift of the h∞ curve (compared with that in Nao/Ki) with 0 K+ on both sides of the membrane (see Discussion).
solutions (Nao/Ki) of Figure 4BB and Figure 7BB, respectively.The plot of r versus Vm in the entire voltage range studied is presented in Figure 8B. The dashed line is the exponential fit of the points at negative potentials (rn(V), Figure 3B). Clearly, this trend is no longer followed at depolarized voltages (see Discussion). Finally, to best compare the voltage dependence of the decay rate r with the steady-state gating of the channels, normalized r values (r/rmax) (squares) were plotted together with the steady-state inactivation and activation (solid circles) points in Nao/Ki solutions of Figure 4BB and Figure 7BB, respectively. It is observed that the apparent reduction of r at depolarized voltages exhibits a qualitative relation with the inactivation state of the channels and that, on the other hand, the inhibition of the drop of GK exerted by hyperpolarized potentials maintains no obvious relation with the voltage dependence of the activation of the channels.
On exposure to 0 K+ solutions on both sides of the membrane, the Shab GK undergoes an irreversible collapse 18. The GK drop occurs while the channels are kept undisturbed at the test HP. An important finding of this work is the demonstration that the collapse of GK follows first-order decay kinetics with a decay rate r that is a complex function of the membrane potential.
Even when the drop of GK has a marked voltage dependence, the stabilizing K+ ions readily dissociate from the channels when the membrane is perfused with 0 K+ solutions, regardless of the membrane potential, and therefore regardless of the associated gating state of the channels, and so the drop of GK cannot be totally halted within the whole range of potentials that were studied.
The observations presented in this article agree with the hypothesized presence of one or more stabilizing K+ sites located either within the pore itself or, as previously proposed, in the external vestibule of the pore, at a site that probably senses the conformational change associated with the slow inactivation of the channels (see below).
Based on the trend observed at negative voltages, it was predicted that at 0mV, the decay rate, r, should be equal to 86min−1 (i.e., r(0)=1.4s−1) and thus should produce a 50% drop of GK after only ∼0.5s in 0 K+. Despite this expected rapid drop of GK, the predicted value of r(0) (and even more so its observed, smaller, value) is very small compared with the rate of K+ permeation through the pore of K+ channels (∼107 s−1). Regarding the latter rate, it is thought that electrostatic repulsion among permeant ions is an important factor for achieving this elevated throughput rate of ions in multi-ion pores. Thus, it is expected that, in the absence of electrostatic repulsion forces, the last ion that leaves K+ channels, in 0 K+ solutions, would do so more slowly. In agreement with this view of permeation, by measuring the rate of entry into the C-type inactivated state, Baukrowitz and Yellen 25 estimated that the rate of exit of the last K+ ion from the Shaker channel is 6.7×103 s−1. This rate remains much larger than the expected (and therefore the observed) rate of decay r(0) of Shab GK.
This previous discussion suggests that the rate-limiting step in GK collapse could be the conformational change that must follow the exit of the stabilizing K+, rendering the channels unable to conduct. Therefore, it appears likely that, regardless of the voltage, the magnitude of r may reflect (approach) the rate of this conformational change. It would be interesting to determine whether the preceding K+ dissociation step attains a value similar to that reported in the study of the Shaker.
At depolarized potentials GK also collapses in 0 K+. The collapse occurs at all the depolarized voltages tested and stands in contrast with the behavior of Shaker channels in which depolarized HPs (≥−40mV) preclude the drop of GK14.
In particular, for potentials above −50mV, observations suggest that the stabilizing K+ dissociates either from channels dwelling in the slow inactivated state or from the fraction of channels that may not be inactivated at steady state. Whatever the case, based on the trend observed at negative potentials, it appears that the development of inactivation greatly slows the decay of GK.
Although the slow inactivation of Shab has not been studied in detail, it is well accepted that the extensively studied slow, C-type, inactivation of Shaker channels involves a constriction of the extracellular portion of the pore 26,27,28. However, and of importance to this work, this constriction is not sufficiently narrow to completely impede the movement of ions between the pore and the extracellular solution, as demonstrated by the ability of external Ba2+ to block the pore of the C-type inactivated Shaker channels 29.
Similarly, in Kv1.3 channels, addition of K+ ions to the external solution increases the rate of recovery from inactivation even if the addition is made after the channels have been inactivated. This suggests that K+ might be able to gain access to the pore of slowly inactivated channels 30.
Taking into account the previously mentioned examples and the results of this work, it appears reasonable to set forth the hypothesis that the slow inactivation of Shab channels does not completely block communication between the pore and the external solution.
Whatever the case, the results of this work qualitatively agree with the view that development of inactivation, at depolarized potentials, slows the GK drop. Therefore, the variation of r with the membrane potential in the entire range of voltages studied was fitted with an equation that considered that: 1), the experimental value of r(0) is a measure of the rate of decay of GK from inactivated channels; and that 2), the voltage dependence of r at depolarized potentials is conferred by the voltage dependence of the probability of the channels being inactivated; and finally that 3), at hyperpolarized voltages, r(V) is given by the empirically founded relation rn(V) (Figure 3B) times the probability of the channels not being inactivated, h∞, as follows: r(V)=rn(V)×h∞+r(0)×(1−h∞).
Fig. 9 presents the fit of r in the entire range of voltages studied with the above equation r(V). The figure shows the plot of the equation with the h∞ curve obtained with 0 K+ (Nao/Ki, Figure 7B) in the external solution (V½=−56mV, z=4.6) (dotted line), together with the fit of the points obtained considering the parameters of the h∞ relation as adjustable parameters (solid line). A visual evaluation shows that even with the parameters of h∞ in Nao/Ki the r(V) equation affords a reasonably good fit of the points. The fit was much better when the parameters of h∞ were adjusted (in this case V½=−59mV, z=3.0). Note that these parameters are close to those of the h∞ curve in Nao/Ki. Their difference can be explained by hypothesizing that, as the internal [K+] decreases, the h∞ curve, in the corresponding Nao/Ki solutions, should become less steep and slightly shifted toward the left along the voltage axis. Finally, the deviation of the fitted curve (solid line) to the points at the more depolarized potentials could likely arise from the contribution that the fraction of channels that may not be inactivated at steady sate (and that therefore collapse from the open state) do to the value of r.
On exposure to 0 K+, GK drops spontaneously while the HP is kept constant at −80mV. An important result of this work lies in the finding that hyperpolarized potentials drastically inhibit the drop of GK. The possibility that this phenomenon could be caused by a shift of the voltage-dependent activation of the channels toward negative potentials in 0 K+ was shown to be unlikely with the demonstration that the GK-Vm curve is quite insensitive to the [K+] across the membrane.
On the other hand, the possibility that the behavior of GK at negative potentials could be caused by a voltage-dependent leakage of K+ ions toward the internal solution through the closed activation gate also seems unlikely because 1), the facilitation that channel activation exerts on the drop of GK is small; and 2), in the case of Shaker, it has been reported that the leak of ions that occurs through the closed activation gate is quite small and not voltage dependent 24.
Finally, the observation that channel activation from −140mV facilitates the drop of GK indicates that the voltage-dependent scant openings that take place at negative voltages may certainly contribute both to the passive drop of GK and to the stabilization afforded by hyperpolarized potentials. How big is this contribution? Because a 5-ms pulse seems to drop ∼1% of GK, and a sixfold longer pulse of 30ms should drop ∼1.5% of GK, and also because of the low probability of opening of Kv channels at negative potentials 20, it seems reasonable to conclude, in the absence of further information, that the scant openings at negative potentials may not explain the full extent of drop of GK that is observed at negative potentials.
With the previous arguments in mind, the following hypothesis can be set forth: 1), GK collapse at negative potentials likely occurs more frequently while the channels are closed than during their scant stochastic openings (although during the latter the drop of GK is facilitated). Thus, 2), part of the inhibition of the GK drop that occurs as the membrane is hyperpolarized may be caused by a voltage-dependent retention of the stabilizing K+ ions in the channels, as the probability of opening becomes much smaller. Finally, 3), as the membrane potential is hyperpolarized, channels may adopt conformations, most likely conformations adopted by the selectivity filter itself, that are progressively more stable in the absence of K+ (for example, the selectivity filter could accommodate Na+ ions, thus gaining stability in 0 K+) (ongoing research agrees with this proposal, F. Gómez-Lagunas, L. D. Islas, and M. Ambriz-Rivas, unpublished observations).
The latter hypothesis is rendered plausible by the presence of K+ channels that are stable in 0 K+ (see Introduction) and also by both experimental observations as well as molecular dynamics simulations of 2TM K+ channels demonstrating that the pore of, at least some, K+ channels is flexible enough to be even endowed with gating abilities (e.g., 31,32,33,34,35.
Which of the K+ sites (S1-S4) that comprise the selectivity filter may adopt a conformation (or geometry) that allows the channels to withstand the removal of K+ at hyperpolarized potentials? Although this question is not easy to answer, our previous work with Shaker channels, whose conductance collapses in 0 K+ with voltage dependence reminiscent of that occurring in Shab (see below, 16), may offer a clue: The collapse of Gk is inhibited by scorpion toxins whose block of the pore is destabilized by external K+ ions 36. The toxins present a conserved lysine, located at position 27 of charybdotoxin, that is thought to interact with the most external K+ site of the selectivity filter (SF) 37,38. That is, it appears that the proper occupancy of only the most external K+ site of the SF is needed to prevent the collapse of the Shaker GK. Therefore, it can be speculated that only the first K+ site of the Shab SF would need to undergo a suitable change for the conductance to be stable at hyperpolarized potentials.
The voltage dependence of r at negative potentials may proceed from a number of factors such as voltage-dependent transitions of the channels as they redistribute among closed states, reorientation of the ions within the pore, and the previously mentioned hypothetical conformational change that stabilizes the conductance. Regarding the possible reorientation of ions within the pore, it has been shown that this can contribute to the voltage-dependent gating of some channels, such as ClC-0 channels, in which it produces an apparent gating charge of ∼1 39. Further work is required to understand the marked voltage dependence of the drop of the Shab GK at negative potentials.
K+ removal exerts variable effects on different K+ channels. It has been proposed that the latter is the consequence of differences in the K+ affinity of the pore of the different channels (e.g., 7,40,41. However, the variable responses that the channels exhibit on K+ removal seem too complex to be explained solely by differences in its K+ affinity, as the following comparison suggests.
Shab behavior on exposure to 0 K+ differs in many aspects from that of Shaker B; for example: 1), Shaker channels remain stable if they are kept undisturbed at the HP during exposure to 0 K+, whereas under the same conditions Shab GK undergoes an exponential decay; 2), the Shaker GK collapses only when the channels are gated by the delivery of activating pulses; 3), in Shaker the collapse of GK is fully reversible, whereas in Shab it is irreversible; 4), depolarized HPs impede the Shaker GK drop, whereas at these potentials the Shab GK falls even faster than at negative potentials; and 5) it appears that in Shaker the collapse of GK occurs during the deactivation of the channels 14,15,16,17,18,36,42, whereas in Shab, GK decays in 0 K+ regardless of the gating state of the channels (although inactivation appears to slow the rate of decay, whereas the delivery of activating pulses facilitates it).
Therefore, it would be expected that mutations abolishing the slow inactivation of Shab would speed the decay of GK at depolarized potentials. In contrast, in the case of Shaker it has been shown that mutations at position 449, located in the extracellular vestibule of the pore, that prevent C-type inactivation, as T449Y and T449V 27, also prevent the collapse of GK16.
Shab channels present a cysteine at the Shaker 449 position, and Shab slow inactivation presents certain properties that differ from those that are characteristic of the typical C-type Shaker inactivation (work in progress). Thus, it would be interesting to determine whether some of the differences in the collapse of the conductance of these channels could be accounted for by the different residues that they present at this critical position.
Another residue that might play a role in the collapse of Shab GK is a cysteine located at position 463, in the S6 helix, because Shaker channels present an alanine at this position, and the mutation A463C speeds the rate of C-type inactivation, and it appears that this prevents the collapse of GK43; see also Discussion of Ambriz-Rivas et al. 18).
Finally, it is important to mention that Armstrong’s laboratory shows that the extent of reduction of the Shaker GK produced by each pulse applied in 0 K+ is greater when the membrane is repolarized to intermediate potentials, at pulse end. The latter was explained by means of the hypothesis that closing to intermediate closed states facilitates GK collapse 16. This behavior is reminiscent of the observation that the rate of decay r of Shab is bigger at intermediate HPs (−30 and −50mV), although in this case this maximum is not related to the deactivation gating of the channels.
Further work is required to understand the molecular and mechanistic bases of the differential response of Shab and Shaker to K+ removal, although, at this point, their differences appear too complex to be explained solely by a difference in K+ affinity for its respective pores.
Regarding the comparative behavior of KcsA and Shab channels under low- or 0 K+ conditions, it has been reported that the pore of KcsA adopts a nonconducting, collapsed, reversible conformation in 3mM K+12, whereas it was shown herein that Shab channels conduct well with only 2mM
in the recording solutions. Further work is needed to determine whether this particular difference is the result of a differential K+ affinity for these pores. On the other hand, in agreement with the stabilizing effect of K+ on Shab GK, it has been shown that the absence of K+ undermines the thermal stability of the KcsA tetramer 13.
Finally, the behavior of Shab on exposure to 0 K+ solutions seems to be similar to that reported in the pioneering studies of Armstrong’s laboratory with the squid K+ channel. This similarity lies in that in the latter the stabilizing K+ also leaves the channels, whereas they are closed at the HP, and in that the GK drop is also irreversible 5,44. It would be interesting to determine whether the decay of the squid K+ channel activity presents a voltage dependence similar to the one reported in this work.
The author thanks Marco Ambriz-Rivas for his participation in some of the experiments in Fig. 7 and J. M. Hernandez for technical assistance. This work was supported by Direccion General de Asuntos del Personal Academico grant IN213406-2 and by Consejo Nacional de Ciencia y Tecnologia grant 40690-Q.
1. (1994). Mutations in the K+ channel signature sequence. Biophys. J. 66, 1061–1067. Abstract | | PubMed
2. (1998). The structure of the potassium channel: molecular basis of K+ conduction and selectivity. Science 280, 69–77. CrossRef | PubMed
3. (2005). Crystal structure of a mammalian voltage-dependent Shaker family K+ channel. Science 309, 897–903. CrossRef | PubMed
4. (1970). Sodium and potassium currents in squid axons perfused with fluoride solutions. J. Gen. Physiol. 211, 623–652. PubMed
5. (1980). Survival of K+ permeability and gating currents in squid axons perfused with K+-free media. J. Gen. Physiol. 75, 61–78. CrossRef | PubMed
6. (1998). Influence of non-P region domains on selectivity filter properties in voltage-gated K+ channels. Receptors Channels 6, 178–188. PubMed
7. (1999). Localization of the K+ lock-in and Ba2+ sites in a voltage gated calcium-modulated channel. Implications for survival of K+ permeability. J. Gen. Physiol. 114, 365–376. CrossRef | PubMed
8. (1993). Anomalous permeation of Na+ through a putative K+ channel in rat superior cervical ganglion neurons. J. Physiol. 468, 441–461. PubMed
9. (1995). Permeation selectivity by competition in a delayed rectifier potassium channel. Science 269, 410–412. PubMed
10. (1997). Delayed rectifier current of bullfrog sympathetic neurons: ion-ion competition, asymmetrical block and effects of ions on gating. J. Physiol. 449, 403–416. PubMed
11. (2000). Regulation of transient Na+ conductance by intra and extracellular K+ in the human delayed rectifier K+ channel Kv1.5. J. Physiol. 523, 575–591. CrossRef | PubMed
12. (2001). Chemistry of ion coordination and hydration revealed by a K+ channel-Fab complex at 2.0Å resolution. Nature 414, 43–48. CrossRef | PubMed
13. (2005). Functional role and affinity of inorganic cations in stabilizing the tetrameric structure of the KcsA K+ channel. J. Gen. Physiol. 126, 271–283. CrossRef | PubMed
14. (1997). Shaker B K+ conductance in Na+ solutions lacking K+ ions: A remarkably stable nonconducting state produced by membrane depolarizations. J. Physiol. 499, 3–15. PubMed
15. (2001). Na+ interaction with the pore of Shaker B K+ channels. Zero and low K+ conditions. J. Gen. Physiol. 118, 639–648. CrossRef | PubMed
16. (1998). Loss of Shaker K channel conductance in 0 K+ solutions: role of the voltage sensor. Biophys. J. 75, 1828–1835. Abstract | Full Text | PDF (187 kb) | PubMed
17. (2001). Dilated and defunct K channels in the absence of K+. Biophys. J. 80, 2704–2714. Abstract | Full Text | PDF (276 kb) | PubMed
18. (2005). K+-dependent stability and ion conduction of Shab K+ channels: a comparison with Shaker channels. Pflugers Arch-Eur J. Physiol. 450, 255–261. PubMed
19. (2002). The open conformation of potassium channels. Nature 417, 523–526. CrossRef | PubMed
20. (1999). Voltage sensitivity and gating charge in Shaker and Shab family potassium channels. J. Gen. Physiol. 114, 723–741. CrossRef | PubMed
21. (1978). Gating currents and charge movements in excitable membranes. Rev. Physiol. Biochem. Pharmacol. 82, 96–190. PubMed
22. (2000). Modulation of the Shaker K+ channel gating kinetics by the S3–S4 linker. J. Gen. Physiol. 115, 193–207. CrossRef | PubMed
23. (2001). Tight steric closure at the intracellular activation gate of a voltage-gated K+ channel. Neuron 32, 649–656. Abstract | Full Text | PDF (303 kb) | CrossRef | PubMed
24. (2003). Defining the conductance of the closed state in a voltage-gated K+ channel. Neuron 10, 61–67. Abstract | | CrossRef | PubMed
25. (1996). Use-dependent blockers and exit rate of the last ion from the multi-ion pore of a K+ channel. Science 271, 653–656. PubMed
26. (1991). Tetraethylammonium blockade distinguishes two inactivation mechanisms in voltage-activated K+ channels. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 88, 5092–5095. CrossRef | PubMed
27. (1993). Effects of external cations and mutations in the pore region on C-Type inactivation of Shaker potassium channels. Receptors Channels 1, 61–71. PubMed
28. (1996). Dynamic rearrangement of the outer mouth of a K+ channel during gating. Neuron 16, 859–867. Abstract | Full Text | PDF (203 kb) | CrossRef | PubMed
29. (1998). Pore accesibility during C-type inactivation in Shaker K+ channels. FEBS Lett. 429, 375–380. CrossRef | PubMed
30. (1996). Recovery from C-Type inactivation is modulated by extracellular potassium. Biophys. J. 70, 798–805. Abstract | | PubMed
31. (2003). Merging functional studies with structures of inward rectifier K+ channels. Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 4, 957–967. PubMed
32. (2004). K channel gating by an affinity-switching selectivity filter. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 101, 3248–3252. CrossRef | PubMed
33. (2005). Activation-coupled inactivation in the bacterial potassium channel KcsA. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 102, 17630–17635. CrossRef | PubMed
34. (2005). Ion conduction and selectivity in K+ channels. Annu. Rev. Biophys. Biomol. Struct. 34,